Question : This question is a plot hole question pertaining mostly to the films and slightly to the books, and wondering whether or not what I think is a plot hole really is. At the end of this film Bella tells Jacob that she loves him. In the book this didn't happen. Then in Eclipse both the film and book Jacob spends the whole time trying to convince Bella that she loves him.
In this film Bella also tells Jacob that although she loves him, she will still choose Edward over him, and in Eclipse the film she basically repeats that statement by saying that her feelings for Jacob don't change, that she loves Edward more and will marry him.
I am aware there two different directors for New Moon and Eclipse so could that be the reason for my confusion? Answer: The change in directors makes no difference as the plot is based off the book. Bella loves Jacob but she feels that she cannot survive without Edward, and therefore loves him more. Separate from membership , this is to get updates about mistakes in recent releases. Addresses are not passed on to any third party, and are used solely for direct communication from this site.
Edward wants to see if it is actually true by calling at Bella's home. When Edward calls, Jacob answers the phone, however, and informs Edward, who is impersonating Carlisle Cullen, that Charlie is at the funeral, referring to Harry, but Edward draws the conclusion that it is Bella's funeral.
Having lost the will to exist as immortal, Edward flees to Italy to see the Volturi peace-keeping vampires who would be able to kill Edward if he broke the vampire laws thus granting him leave of a world without Bella. Alice foresees this however, and in a panic she and Bella hasten to stop him. Bella and Alice rush to Italy to stop Edward.
Bella stops Edward from stepping into the sunlight by running with all her energy to save him, he is happy to see Bella and know she is alive. She states you didn't have to feel guilty or anything, I can let you go now. He states you'll never have to let go. The reason why Edward decided to reveal himself is because Aro refused to kill him at first so he tries to break the law by an act that would have revealed the existence of vampires and invoked the wrath of the Volturi.
Instead, all three of them are brought before the Volturi for judgment. Aro, the most exuberant of the Volturi and their overall leader, is very curious about Bella and her power to block Edward's mind reading. So he sets up tests for her, and finds out that neither he nor Jane can affect her. Intriguied, Aro asks if she wants to join the Volturi when she is a vampire, but she refuses.
One of the leaders, Caius, states that Edward has still broken the law by revealing the vampire world to a human, violating the one rule of keeping the existence of vampires a secret. Therefore, they decree that Bella must be killed because she knows too much about vampires. Aro however says that Bella may still live if Edward will turn her into a vampire himself.
They are saved when Alice shows Aro a vision of the future. Aro, who can also read minds, sees Bella becoming a Vampire and is satisfied. The three are free to leave on one condition: Bella must be turned into a vampire, and soon. When they return to Forks, Bella wakes up to see Edward and believes she had drowned or is dreaming and starts going into hysterics. Edward tells her what he was doing before he heard about her dying, that he left to try and protect her because, in spite of his words, he still loves her deeply.
But she still believes that he is a dream. He finally manages to make her believe he is real by kissing her. He also explains that he will never leave her again. She is happy to have him back, but he upsets her when he says that he won't damn her soul by turning her into a vampire.
Bella knows that she must become a vampire, knowing that the Volturi are incredibly powerful and will surely punish them for breaking their deal. She then tells him that she is going to ask his family to vote on the matter. Everybody says yes to her being a vampire except Edward and Rosalie, with the latter only voting no because she herself resents the life of a vampire and feels obliged to at least vote otherwise.
Edward is angry at his family, but Carlisle himself will not risk Edward running off to the Volturi if Bella dies as a mortal. Edward takes Bella home, and tells Bella that he will turn her himself after she marries him. Bella is subsequently healed from her psychological wounds, and her life begins anew.
The book ends with Bella being grounded for leaving Forks without permission. Because she hadn't gone to La Push in a while, Jacob thinks that Edward was keeping Bella away, so he drops off the motorcycles at her house, which makes Charlie furious. They slam each other into things, hurl each other through the air, and grab onto each other.
A group of people is led into a room full of vampires. The implication is that they are going to be killed by the vampires. We hear terrified screams coming from the room. Content that may disturb children Under 8 In addition to the violent scenes mentioned above, this movie contains some scenes and images that could scare or disturb children under eight.
For example: The movie features giant threatening werewolves with snarling teeth. Teenage boys change from humans to giant wolves. In several scenes, Bella wakes up from a nightmare screaming in terror. Animals growl in the background. Vampires have glowing red eyes. A woman has a badly disfigured face. We hear that her partner a werewolf caused the injury during an uncontrollable fit of rage.
Edward appears in ghost-like inky black images. Vampires move with supernatural speed and fight with supernatural strength. From Some of the violent scenes and images mentioned above could also scare or disturb children in this age group. Sexual references This movie contains some sexual references. Bella tells Edward that he will not want her when she is old and a grandmother. Bella jokes about dating a man who is over years old Edward.
She touches his naked chest and runs her fingers through his hair. She asks him if he will run away with her. He says no and jumps out the window again. The comment has sexual connotations. Alcohol, drugs and other substances This movie contains some references to substance use. Jacob gives Sam a funny look. She says no, and tells her to get out and go and do something with her friends.
She calls Jessica up, and we see her and Jessica walking out of a movie theatre. Bella is distracted by a group of guys on bikes her whistle at her and Jessica.
She has a sudden memory of any time she was in trouble, Edward would save her. Suddenly, a misty version of Edward is right in front of her. As soon as she gets scared enough, she tells the guy to stop, and the misty Edward disappears. Jacob pulls the tarp off the bed of her truck to reveal 2, really awful looking bikes.
He says he could probably fix them up. He goes to pick them up off the truck, and she warns him that they are very heavy, but he easily lifts one and sets it on the ground, and she is again amazed at how buff he is. The next montage is of them hanging out and working on the bikes together, obviously spending a lot of time together. On the way to finally test out the bikes, Bella quickly pulls over when she sees a group of bare-chested guys gang up on one of their own and throw him over a cliff.
Jacob explains that they are just cliff diving, nothing really big, a huge rush, but that most everyone else goes from a lower spot. Bella is a little surprised to hear the sinicism, and Jacob explains that Embry has joined them, even though he used to be terrified of Sam and his gang.
It really has Jacob irked, and he tells Bella about how now Sam is just eyeing him. They get to a little secluded spot where they can test out their bikes, and as Bella straddles hers she sees misty Edward again. He tells her not to do this, and she jumps the gun a bit and nearly runs Jacob over. She gives it another go and gets the bike going, but is going really fast. She protests, but he points out that she is bleeding.
She feels her head, where she is indeed dripping blood, and apologizes quickly. A few days later at school, Bella decides to go sit with her old friends at their table, and overhears Angela talking about something she saw in the woods — a really big animal, like a bear or something. Bella believes her, and tells about the tracking her dad has been doing. In the movie, Bella sits between the two boys, both of whom have a hand out obviously poised to hold hers.
She just sits with her hands decidedly clasped. She is afraid of making him something more than a friend, just to have him leave. He promises that he will never hurt her. Over the next several days, Bella calls Jake again and again, but he never returns calls and Billy tells her he has mono.
One day, Charly and Harry are going to go fishing, but Charlie offers to stay home. Bella says not to worry, and after they leave she randomly takes off for the reservation to see Jacob. She shows up at his house, and he is outside in the pouring rain, shirtless, a tattoo, and with much shorter hair. She remembers the meadow as a beautiful place with lots of flowers, and especially beautiful Edward. But when she gets to the meadow, it is brown and dead.
The pain of being there hits her, and she nearly collapses. When she gets up, though, Laurant is there. Suddenly, she sees misty Edward. Laurant sees right through it, and misty Edward tells her to lie better. Victoria, mad about Edward killing her mate, wants to kill his mate, but she wants to inflict serious pain.
0コメント